John Wilmot, second Earl of Rochester (1674 [anon. pub.])
Genre: verse satire, and translation.
Form: most are heroic couplets (rhyming iambic pentameter), but "Upon Nothing" is composed of three-line stanzas, two pentameter lines and a hexameter, rhyming aaa (!!!).
Characters: Various allegorical characters ("Upon Nothing") are mixed with court and town types (the Debauchee, the Postboy, the courtiers and pimps, "courtesans" and open prostitutes) who made the Restoration court a famous and notorious place. His more ribald poems openly name members of the court known to have engaged in licentious sexual conduct, but not always naming them in an un-admiring fashion. (Additional readings in Rochester, especially the satires "Upon Nothing," "Against Mankind," and the passage from Seneca referred to below, are available in the standard scholarly print edition of his works (826.3 R67Hp 1988), but beware the extreme obscenity of the other lyrics. The advantage of reading contemporary satire in a scholarly edition is that the more obscure in-jokes about court personalities will be explained in the footnotes. Reading Rochester's footnotes is a form of education that no well-rounded liberal arts graduate ought to omit.)
Summary:
He's not dismissive of functional knowledge, however, so Hoffberger's safe: "But thoughts are given for action's government; / Where action ceases, thought's impertinent" (94-5). It's the old "gnosis-praxis" argument from Sidney's "Defense." However, he pushes it further and (voila, the 'Sixties!) says: "Our sphere of action is life's happiness, / And he who thinks beyond, thinks like an ass" (96-7). He claims that "right reason" will bring our passions and intellects into a balance that will not extinguish pleasure, so he's not against all reason, just oppressive reason. He accepts limits on desire, but demands that desire be allowed its function, and reminds us that most of us rarely can pursue desire because we are bound by fear (139ff.).
At l. 174 (as in the case of "Upon Nothing"--see a pattern?) he turns to the court and the church, which receive the full force of his lash. In ll. 212-219, he almost seems to be evoking the Parson of Canterbury Tales in imagining a good churchman, humble, continent, and sensible. However, like Donne ("Song: Go And Catch a Falling Star"), he turns away from this rare beast (as he imagines him) and claims "Man differs more from man, than man from beast" (221).
Issues and Research Sources:
Rochester lived during the era in which the Royal Society for the study of science was founded by Charles II.
For the general website address of "Voice of the Shuttle" which contains a variety of tools and information for Seventeenth-Century studies, click here. Be especially careful, however, when using VOS material as a source for papers. Some of its materials are distinctly not scholarly (undergraduate student work, popular sites, etc.). Keep your wits about you and test your sources like a good scholar.